American Idol...who's going? - 2 hours 'til showtime!

MommyToAshley wrote: I would have to say Kimberly based on just last night, but guess we will see.

Schnoogly replied: I missed it 'cause we went to see XMen!!!! It was awesome. We taped Buffy so couldn't tape AI too. Can anyone give me a recap??

Steph

CantWait replied: I knew it would be Josh, his time was up.

jdkjd replied: Was it Josh? I missed it...

Kaitlin'smom replied: Yep Josh went............its getting tougher to pick who will go now!

I voted for Clay, its was harder to get in but I did 5 times! woohoo! I like Josh but he was to country for american idol. but hay he made it to the top 4! WTG! I bet he will get some sort of deal out of it.

MommyToAshley replied: Yep, Josh went. Kimberly and Josh were in the bottom two, but Josh went.


For those of you that watched it, Did you notice when Simon was commenting on who should go this week he said....

"Last week it should have been Josh to go and this week it should have been Kimberly to go" (Notice the past tense "should have been" )

This is before, they announced who was kicked off. Soooo, even though they aren't suppose to know who is going, I think they do. I think they knew that Ruben was in the bottom two last week and that look by Simon was staged. Just MHO, but I still love the show.

maliksmommy replied: I thought it was Josh's time to go even though he did a really good job on Tuesday night but looking at overall I think the 3 that are left are the best. These last shows are going to be hard to choose, I still love Ruben though

5littleladies replied: I knew Josh would go this week but I sure thought Ryan was rude when he announced it. Did you see Josh's wife? She was so sad!!

Kaitlin'smom replied: Well I almost missed when Ryan anounced it he said it so fast! But they had been waiting long enough he just cut to the point.

Hillbilly Housewife replied: Jennifer you changed your avatar again? cute!

MommyToAshley replied: WHo cried when Josh brought his baby up on stage and was singing to her?

I sure did!!!

Kaitlin'smom replied: I thought it was sweet but did not cry. I did cry when he started proud to be an american! I need to go out and get that!

5littleladies replied:
I cry everytime I hear that but hearing a Marine singing just made it 10 times better!!

(And yes I changed my avatar again! I can't decide which picture I like best!!)

MommyToAshley replied:
I cried at that too! I am such a sap! LOL! I keep Kleenex in business!

Kaitlin'smom replied: well then I know what you will always need!