Amerian Idol - WARNING: SPOLIER LISTED

Kaitlin'smom wrote: I did not get to see it but DH did and told me about it sounds like it was good.

I am happy with it this time

A&A'smommy replied: Never mind lol I just went to the website... but I would still like to know the other thing..

also did they do a bottom three this time and I would like to know who was in that too please

My2Beauties replied: Not me WIsh it would have been the other guy on the couch! I didn't get to see it neither, I was at Desiree's softball game until late and we got home right as it was going off, but we asked Brian's mom and dad and we were so PO'd! I didn't like him as much as some of the others but definitely think this wasn't his week, now next week yes he should go but the this week should've been the other guy! HE CANNOT SING

AshleyRose replied: I liked that guy a lot and I think that anyone who thinks he doesn't have a great voice is lying to them self. He didn't have the look though and the look shouldnt matter. That other kid is a complete flop but hes got the look... it really hurts me inside to know people vote upon those things . The guy who got booted was funny and genuine and had a awesome voice.. he was also a great performer regardless of his look and past... everyone here has a dirty little secret or something they did that wasn't necessarily right... unfortunately for him, the press got hold of it and blew it out of proportion along with telling the world. You never heard his side of it either...

Put yourself in that position...

and i wont forget his poor face while watching his "life" on Idol... he kept biting his lip to prevent crying.. you could tell...

DansMom replied: I thought the bottom two belonged there. The top three were definitely a cut above, and I think the other on the couch will go next week. It will be tough when there are only three left!

My2Beauties replied:
I'm with you! I liked him too, I thought he could sing. They were talking about him on the radio this morning saying he couldn't sing and stuff, I'm thinking puhlease - he does have talent! I mean I don't think he deserved to win becuase there were others that were better than him but the other dude should have been a long freaking time ago, way before Jessica Ciera - she could sing too

Boys r us replied: It didn't really matter, it was either this week or next week for BOTH of the bottom two..ya know! The other 3 are DEFINITELY better!

AshleyRose replied:
No, he didn't deserve to win.. but he shouldn't have gone before the other flake. It just bothers me how some people vote and judge others...


and I hope carrie does not win because she performs horribly. awesome voice, yes but she is stiff as a board out there on stage... kinda like paula's eyebrows...

My2Beauties replied: Now I love Carrie because she can sing her booty off! She is still an amateur so she is probably just really nervous but the girl can sing and with time she'll get loose on the stage!

AshleyRose replied:
Oh, I totally agree... she is an awesome singer!

If she does win then she will most likely learn how to be a better performer.. and if that doesn't work maybe they should prescribe her some muscle relaxers... LOL .

I think she or vonzell will win..

Bo is good but the quality of his voice isn't as powerful as the girls.. I know someone is good when they give me goosebumps when they sing...

ammommy replied:
Carrie has a great country voice, so you'll probably see a CD of hers even if she doesn't win. She sort of reminds me of Shania Twain. When she tries to do pop, it just doesn't work. She does need some performance coaching, though.

As for the guy that was booted, I was amazed at how good his R&B song was. That was the first time that I heard him when I didn't cringe. He has a very limited range, though, and it's hard to be something other than a one hit wonder with those vocals.

Hopefully, the other one will bite the dust next week. I'm still not sure how he's made it so far

GO BO!!!

amymom replied: Well, so much for spoilers!!

I am happy with this week's results.

Kaitlin'smom replied:
see thats why I wanted that person to go I was always boeard watching them, sure he could sing but BORING, at least the other bottem person had some personaltiy, and yes hopefully next week that one will be gone as well

Kaitlin'smom replied:


oh well

amynicole21 replied: I"m happy he's finally gone... should have happened weeks ago. His voice is ok, but he picked horrible songs and couldn't perform worth a darn. The other guy on the couch shouldn't have even made it into to top 10! Ugh - he is awful and makes me change the channel every time he's singing. One down, one to go

jcc64 replied: ITA with Amy.
Regarding the image thing- I agree that person's look is well, that person's look. But I don't think that's the only reason for his outcome. Ruben was hardly a stud, kwim? I think that person went as far as he could with the limitations of his talent.
And sorry about the spoiler thing- but if you didn't know by now who were all talking about, my post certainly wasn't gonna be the deal breaker.
I think if you don't want the surprise ruined before you see it, don't read the thread. Doesn't that make a little more sense, or am I alone here? Kinda hard to have a conversation without blowing it for someone, whether or not you actually say the name.

amymom replied:
I agree we ought to mark the thread. **SPOILER DO NOT READ**

It would be much easier to respond in such a thread. Good idea.

Jamison'smama replied: Okay, not sure why we do this with no spoilers anywy--it is always obvious in the first post

Anyway, before we are too hard on the public, we have to remember who is probably doing the majority of the voting---teeny-bopper girls and who will they vote for....blondie. He may not be great but I doubt they are sending too many votes to the others. I know many people my age are watching but rarely vote. Okay, I have voted but I put in my one or two votes as compared to the younger folks who may spend all two hours re-dialing.--Yep I voted for Anwar but he appealed to an older crowd--the non-voting crowd.

Anyone out there voting?

Kaitlin'smom replied:
yep either DH or I alot even more now since we wanted him gone....

sorry I will go change the title and we can say the name

jcc64 replied: Ds age 12 votes all the time. But I agree with who he's voting for, so I encourage it.

Kaitlin'smom replied: okay who wants to say it?



anyone?

ammommy replied: Yeah! Scott's gone!!!

K, I had to say it.

I'll also admit that I vote and have ever since Bo ended up in the bottom 3 the first time. Tuesday, it took me an hour and 28 minutes to get through (yep, I kept track) Thank heaven's for redial

TANNER'S MOM replied: I vote on 2 cells and my house!

DS also votes on her cell..

I don't sit there all night..but some on in my house is voting at all times!

Mel

DansMom replied: I vote several times, usually for two people, and more for the one I liked most that night. Been voting mostly for Bo, with some votes for Vonzell thrown in.

bucky replied: Bo all the way!!!!!!!!